Welcome back to Dark Corners streaming. We're looking at Guillermo del Toro's Frankenstein, available for a short period in cinemas and now streaming on Netflix. Any new version of Frankenstein arrives with a particular set of expectations. Partly because if you didn't enjoy this one, there will be another soon, and partly because there are numerous adaptations available, each distinct enough to coexist.
Mark Kermode noted, "There is no definitive version of Frankenstein." Despite this, a new adaptation from a modern master of horror, Guillermo del Toro, comes with significant expectations. Having been on del Toro's agenda for years, the film has undergone multiple iterations and comes with a predictably mixed reception. Given how deeply embedded Frankenstein is in popular culture, it's challenging to create a version that pleases everyone.
This rendition stars Oscar Isaac in the titular role, Jacob Elordi as the creature, and Mia Goth. Notably, Lars Mikkelsen also features, adding depth to the cast. Del Toro delivers his signature style: a blend of modern sensibilities with classic gothic storytelling. What surprises many is its allegiance to Mary Shelley's original novel, which is more than anticipated.
The film is imbued with references to previous adaptations, like James Whale's classic and Hammer's versions, as well as nods to works like The Ninth Configuration. Much of the film remains faithful to Shelley's original, although it introduces its own changes. Such changes are not slavish but rather respectful of the source material.
While visually stunning and well-performed, the film does have its limitations. Critics have observed that while it has moments of intense horror, it sometimes feels it doesn't take enough risks. Oscar Isaac's character has abundant resources, posing questions about his isolation, and some roles, like Christoph Waltz's, seem under-explored.
Ultimately, del Toro's Frankenstein is an intelligent, engaging adaptation that challenges viewers without alienating them. Its run-time is quite long, yet it remains compelling throughout, balancing horror with human depth. This adaptation reaffirms the timelessness of Shelley's tale, portraying it with a fresh yet classic touch.