Home > Reviews > Review: 'I Know What You Did Last Summer' 2025 Attempts Nostalgia with Mixed Results


Review: 'I Know What You Did Last Summer' 2025 Attempts Nostalgia with Mixed Results


Exploring the new sequel to 'I Know What You Did Last Summer,' this review discusses its attempt at nostalgia and where it falls short.

The "I Know What You Did Last Summer" franchise returns with a new sequel, aiming to capture the spirit of its predecessors while appealing to fans of the original series. This review dives into the film's attempt to recreate the 90s slasher vibe in a modern context, drawing parallels with other legacy sequels like "Scream."

The movie picks up on the typical slasher plot, involving an accident and an ominous note leading to a series of murders. While familiar faces like Freddy Prinze Jr. and Jennifer Love Hewitt make a return, the film heavily relies on nostalgia, which might not pay dividends for every viewer.

Despite offering some entertaining moments, especially in its stalking sequences, much of the action feels like a rehash of earlier films. The movie's attempt to throw back to the '90s through dialogue and style may not resonate with everyone, as some viewers might feel like it veers into a 2000s slasher territory instead.

Characters deliver lines that seem out of place for the era it tries to evoke, missing the balance of seriousness and humor that marked the best of the genre. Additionally, its efforts to introduce new themes are undermined by a somewhat underwhelming script.

Overall, this release struggles to justify its existence, offering more of the same rather than reimagining or innovating. It fails to bring anything new to the series that would make it a must-watch, especially when compared to simply revisiting the original movie. However, for those interested in legacy sequels and nostalgic for the '90s, it might just hit the spot.

If you're a fan of slasher classics, the return to familiar ground could be appealing, but don't expect anything groundbreaking. Perhaps it serves as a reminder that sometimes revisiting the past is best done through its original, untouched experiences.